So when are you breaking the law in file sharing? The US economy will never remain dominate if this legal crap persists....Recording industry will seek out P2P file sharing users and sue them.
Is it when you download an MP3? What if you own the vinyl? What about if you expose MP3 files to the network? What if you own the vinyl, and you share the file? Is it the sharing that violates the law, or is it the downloading of a shared file for a track for which you do not own the vinyl? And who is breaking the law - the sharer or the downloader? And when I say vinyl, I include any other legally purchased media.