| |
|
Saturday, March 27, 2004
|
|
KING OF THE BLOGS FINAL ROUND
CHALLENGE AND WHOLE BLOG REVIEWS
The Challenge Question:
The blogosphere has just been invaded by space aliens from the planet
Zebnon. As King of the Blogs it is your duty to meet the threat. In
doing this you must make a delegation of bloggers to rise up and meet
the aliens. You are excluded from including members of the judging
panel on this delegation (no butt-kissing!) For each member you must
include a reason why.
Walloworld:
GOOD POINTS: As the reigning King of the Blogs, he did what all
bloodthirsty tryants do: ignored all the rules of civilzed behavior
that apply to lesser beings. Despite the "no butt-kissing" rule, he
managed to work in gratuitous links to 2 of the judges. Since one of
them was me and the other was Susies delectable gluteous, this counts
in his favor. Also, it was a well-written and entertaining post with a
nice swipes at several "oddball teams with a mission" movies.
BAD POINTS: Channelling the spirit of a coked-up Johnny Cochrane, he
went on and on, answering a simple question so many times that for the
next seven months, America's Presidential campaign discussion will
revolve around how to best handle the nationwide pixel shortage caused
by Bill's bloviating windbaggery. Also, a tragic dearth of self-linkage.
SCORE: 9
Irritable Blog Syndrome:
GOOD POINTS: With the unswerving arrogance befitting royalty, The Bull
pointedly assumed the title of Queen in her essay. This kind of naked
power-lust is something I could kneel before. Also, she puts some
serious firepower into the mix by choosing Misha, who does rage better than anyone alive. Well constructed, with a carefully crafted "breaking news story" theme.
BAD POINTS: Didn't link to Helen's "blogging nekkid" picture when mentioning her name.
SCORE: 9
Blog Supplement:
GOOD POINTS: Demonstrating two-faced deceptive diplomacy worthy of Colonel Green,
Hbee avoids the "direct show of strength" tactic chosen by the other
two contenders and showcases blogs so bad that it took me an hour to
read his post because I kept running away from my computer, screaming
from the crippling horror of it all. Bonus points for demonstrating
that, not matter what pathetic inanity I may post, my blog could suck a
LOT worse. Anyone afflicted with "blogger's doubt" must read this post.
BAD POINTS: No matter how much Clorox I drink, I can't get the taste of that "Poor Lemur Poem" out of my mouth.
SCORE: 10
The Whole Blog: Technical Merit & Personality
Here are some technical things I like to see on a blog:
Comments enabled
Permalinks working
E-mail contact info available
Blogger's name/pseudonym prominently displayed
Site search feature enabled
Link to an "About Me" post on the sidebar
Blogger's gender is easily discernable
Blogroll
Readable font style & size
Readable color scheme (for example, NOT bright red type on bright green background)
Divisions between posts clearly marked
Paragraphing in entries (NOT just writing one fat block of text)
Aside from the tech stuff, I also like to see a blogger's personality
shining through, to remind us of the person behind the words.
Walloworld:
GOOD POINTS: All his technical points are still in fine working
order. Personality-wise, I gotta love the way he put up the short
descriptions by the judges' links. I also enjoy the "recent entries by
category" feature.
BAD POINTS: Ummm... [searching desperately for something mean to
say]... uh, he's still a lawyer... uh... oh! He needs to capitalize his
category names.... Rats! Who am I kidding?
SCORE: 10
Irritable Blog Syndrome:
GOOD POINTS: Technical points - all good. I also love the way she fixed
that "no, really, I'm a girl" problem, as well as finally figuring out
where to put that horrid & disturbing logo image (which actually
starts to grow on you after a while). Speaking of which, although I
dinged King Bill for using the "extended entries" feature too much,
it's actually a blessing with Bull's entries, because it obscures Mr.
Flashy Guts.
BAD POINTS: I specifically asked for bikini pictures! Where are my
bikini pictures? Oh well. A couple minor nits, probably leftover
untidynesses from the last re-design & not worth deducting for: You
might want to shrink the left column just a touch, because occasionally
a letter or two will spill over the edge of the background onto Mr. FG.
Also, you should put either more space or a line or something between
the bottom of one post and the top of the next, just for esthetics. I'm
not deducting because the tiny print followed by bolded titles is a
satisfactory visual divider. I'm just saying it looks a little crowded.
SCORE: 10
Blog Supplement:
GOOD POINTS: What a nice young man. And such a tidy sidebar! Not
crowded with dirty pictures & blog affiliations like most bloggers.
Although I suppose it will
get filled up in time. I like the way he works that puppy theme for all
it's worth, both as a header and a post divider. Brings a sense of
unity to the page.
BAD POINTS: Piddled on my rug. BAD DOG! Anyway, there are some
important technical items missing. First, no 'search' feature. This
could cost you linkage down the road. Let's say I vaguely remembered
something you once said about some stand-up comedian, and I wanted to
quote and link you. If you have search, I can find the entry in
question easily & I'll probably take the time. Without it, I'm too
lazy to try to force it through Google. Second, there's no "about me"
post. Which is an even bigger problem since with a name like Hbee, your
gender is indeterminate (although I did find something indicating
maleness in one of the entries, so...). Besides, I'd like to know a
little bit more about the author. A third, but non-deductable item is
that I couldn't find a link to your main blog page. As a courtesy to
your readers, you might consider putting such a link in your entry
template somewhere near the permalink. Anyway, although I've mentioned
several items, I'm only dinging lightly in view of your recent
de-blogspotification.
SCORE: 9
posted by Harvey at 5:37:14 PM permalink HOME
|
|
|
© Copyright 2005 Harvey Olson.
Last update: 9/10/2005; 4:36:21 PM.
|
|
| March 2004 |
| Sun |
Mon |
Tue |
Wed |
Thu |
Fri |
Sat |
| |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
| 7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
11 |
12 |
13 |
| 14 |
15 |
16 |
17 |
18 |
19 |
20 |
| 21 |
22 |
23 |
24 |
25 |
26 |
27 |
| 28 |
29 |
30 |
31 |
|
|
|
| Feb Apr |
MAIN ARCHIVES
CATEGORY ARCHIVES
GRAFFITI CURRENCY
200 WORDS OR LESS
FILTHY LIES
LOVE NOTES
PRECISION GUIDED HUMOR
KING OF THE BLOGS
|
|