Woman kept alive in hopes of saving baby. A 26-year-old pregnant woman with cancer whose brain function ceased last month is being kept alive with a respirator in hopes ... [USATODAY.com Nation - Top Stories]
This story is riddled with so many ethical and moral questions that I just do not know where to begin. I can only shake my head at the husband's decision, but, like the Schivo case, he has the right to make the decision.
That the story involves those of the Catholic religion should not surprise you. What should surprise and make you question is that man (or in this case medicine) is using her as a husk, a carrying case, because she herself is worth so much more. That her husband feels this way indicates to me that this was not an easy decision for him. What we should all be thinking about is what are the real ramifications of technology. Not even 20 years ago, this woman would have died and we would not even be having this conversation.
Medical ethicists will have to wrestle with the implications of what this sort of decision really means, but it brings to my mind the sort of cloning that was done by the Bene Tleilax in the Frank Herbert Dune novels. For those who do not read science fiction or have not read beyond the first book, the Tleilax grow their clones (called ghola) in axlotl tanks. Frank Herbert may or may not have had in mind what the tanks were, but by the end of the series written by his son Brian and Kevin J. Anderson, we learn that an axlotl tank is nothing more than a brain dead woman.
If you do not find this disturbing, think about this. Frank originally wrote Dune in the late 1950s. Finally, consider this. He also wrote a book of bio-terrorism 30 years before we even considered some of the consequences. If you can find The White Plague I encourage you to read it. If you have not already read Dune and the prequels to Dune, you cannot begin to image what sort of issues Jason Torres decision brings into focus.
8:23:53 AM
|