vulgar morality : Blogging for the relationship between morality and freedom
Updated: 12/2/2008; 10:29:07 PM.

 

Subscribe to "vulgar morality" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.

 
 

Friday, November 21, 2008

A THOUGHT EXPERIMENT (CONT'D):  To what extent are the copies of me in other worlds still me?  A valid question.  I don't know how far one can stretch the concept of "possible permutations" -- but assuming the normal human equipment, an entire world separates me from all my other versions.  I become them only when I act like them.  If I run from violence, I enter the world in which I am a coward.  That is the only world I know.  Somewhere in the infinity of worlds, there are multiple courageous versions of me:  but they are not me at all. 

 

Of course, there must exist an indefinite number of Almost Me:  copies who look, sound, and behave exactly like my present self, except for some trivial difference -- they have taken up tap dancing, say, or are fanatical about lacrosse rather than baseball.  Can a trivial difference make a man?  I'll say this:  if I'm tap dancing, I'm not me.

 

Since I slide inexorably from one world to another, a relationship undoubtedly exists between Now Me and Next Me.  I'm not flying blind.  I have a vision of the world into which I expect my actions to take me.  Unfortunately, this vision is partial and flawed.  I have been granted the power to act, and to know right from wrong.  I can't peer across worlds.  I can't prophesy the future:  only surprises are predictable.

 

I determine the moral tone of the world I live in, never its material qualities.

 

For some reason, I find it cold comfort to reflect on the endless series of Better Me, men who were strong when I was weak and generous when I was mean.  Hooray for them, I guess.  Somewhere there is even a Very Best Me, who never once shirked his duty.  All I can say is, I hope he's bald and ugly.  (But, depressingly, there must exist a me who is perfect in every way.)

 

Far more rewarding to consider Evil Me -- the monster I would become but for my massive exertions of virtue.  Little useful can be said about this cad, other than those who remember the original Star Trek would recognize him instantly:  he's the me with the goatee.


5:55:22 PM    comment []

© Copyright 2008 Vulgar Morality.



Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website.
 


November 2008
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30            
Oct   Dec

Favorites

A million bloggers shouting


Art and morality


Tyranny of modern art


Women on the verge


Tradition and morality


Doh! Raising my kids on the Simpsons


Disruption and democracy


America and the Machiavellian moment


Freedom through the looking-glass


Moral monsters, viewed from afar


Between the good and the great


The decline and fall of everybody


Morality and the empty cradle


Terri Schiavo and human vanity


I,Robot vs Chinese room experiment


Thoughts on the tsunami


The origins of evil


Resistance is futile


The span of a life


Jefferson and American virtue,1


Jefferson and American virtue,2


Jefferson and American virtue,3


Dictators: Moral universe of totalitarianism


Dictators: Guilt of the people


Protagoras, or two paths to virtue


Gorgias, and the pursuit of happiness