|
Tuesday, May 23, 2006 |
All Along the Datacloud
Attributed Quotation as Plagiarism. In a somewhat odd piece at Plagiarism Today, Jonathan Bailey takes weblogs to task for failing to add enough "original" content to material they quote from other sites. The piece begins (in both title and initial paragraph) by labeling the practice "the new plagiarism" (and cites a few sources that agree with him), a move that he later admits was a mistake (in an update at the end of the article) because plagiarism and fair use of intellectual property are different issues - he's apparently more interested in the latter. (He also sounds a little resentful and places the blame for this miscommunication on the reader, and so far has failed to update the incendiary title and opening paragraph. I guess he's enjoying the notoriety.) But aside from that issue, there are some fundamental problems with Bailey's attempt at linking intellectual property theft to weblogs that are primarily attributed quotes and links: These sites, which for this article I'll simply call "gray", are generally identified by a large number of very short posts, with much of it in block quotes or otherwise directly lifted content. Though they meticulously credit their sources, bowing to more traditional rules for blog attribution, and work to... [datacloud]
6:38:14 PM
|
|
© Copyright 2009 Gary Santoro.
|
|
|
|
|
|
M E D I A B U R N
<
#
phoenix bloggers
?
>
Search This Website
Subscribe to the Mediaburn news feed if you have a Radio Userland Weblog
RSS Blog Syndication
|
|
|
|
|
|