Updated: 12/2/2002; 3:06:36 PM.
Jack Vaughan's Radio Weblog
        

Sunday, November 03, 2002

Berners-Lee on the Web radio
When the inventor of the World Wide Web speaks, we listen, at least if we are in earshot. Tim Berners-Lee's recent appearance on NPR's Science Friday raised some interesting issues, that point to what is ahead for the Web. The toughest days are still to come perhaps for Berners-Lee, the Web originator and steward, as commercialism and television-like attributes spread across his baby.

It could be worse: Look at the fate of email.

The role of patents, said Berners-Lee, "is a very difficult issue." And, he adds, this is one of the ways in which "the whole thing could come off the rails and come to a horrible halt."

Open technology was the force behind the explosive growth of the Web, he said. So people and companies have to find a way to see value in making sure they let the 'common increase make the general foundation of technology bigger, so you can build exciting [one might guess, proprietary] technology on top of it.


Quito Covered in Ash by Volcanic Eruption -Reuters, Nov 3, 2002
China Launch Spacecraft in Manned Orbital Prep -Reuters, Nov 3, 2002
Rich Gave in at Climate Talks to Protect Kyoto Pact -Reuters, Nov 2, 2002
Court agrees with most parts of Microsoft settlement -ADTmag.com, Nov 2, 2002

The radio discussion was also notable for Berners-Lee's apt impression of a modem engaging in an ASCII handshake.

Also of interest on the show was a discussion with IBM Almaden lab molecule-level chip makers

Links
Science Friday for Nov 2, 2002 -Nov 2
Conversation with Tim Berners-Lee -Nov 2

Poe Boys, Long Way from Home
The links between philosophy, spirit (or religion) and science were strong before the Renaissance, no doubt. Since then, all have been on their merry ways.

A recent PBS show on Galileo focused on the now familiar battle between Galileo and the Roman Catholic Church that seems to be the point that marks the birth of modern science, and the last days of alchemy. A somewhat off beat book of 1980 takes a somewhat different tact.

In "Galileo", Stillman Drake states that Galileo's argument was not with the church. This may be grasping at straws, the societies of his oppressors were intertwined, but it is worth a look see.

Galileo did knuckle under to a church that did not want to look at empirical contravention, but — Galielo's daughter was a nun, and they kept in touch, and he seemed willing in instances to distinguish between the church's work and its workers— the nonreligious theorists whose pet models were under attack might have been his real nettle. G's bigger problem may have been with the philosophers whose theories took a drubbing in the vise of his logic and data, at least per Drake Stillman.

But the fact that publication of his inquisition's transcript came at a time that debated Darwin — when science and religion were more firmly on different rails in a wholly other era than his own — is an important guide as to how Galileo's differences with the church were likely to be perceived.

Really will talk about Poe, honestly
None of which brings to mind a recent Times item on Edgar Allan Poe and his little known prose poem Eureka. Writer Emily Eakin notes that Poe, without the benefit of experimental data, took a swipe at cosmology and proposed a type of Big Bank way back. Writer Tom Siefgried describes such prophesies as 'theoretical anticipation'. The book here says that Poe was a mystic poet not afeared of philosophy or theory or science, really.

And, it is worth noting that the non-mystical Poe's credentials were considerable, having achieved the best math scores to that date in time as a math student at West Point. Lee or Grant must have wondered what could have been.

A bit more on Galileo

A bit more on Galileo: He is at the first great instantiation of modern science. Other's probably earned the wrath of his church. But his science survived the encounter as science by name. And religion and science have been on different apparent paths since then. Philosophers don't quote him; scientists do.

His grapple as the Starry Messenger was with the philosophers that did not want no mountains on no moon, Electra!

Eakins on What did Poe Know about cosmology and when did he know it? NYT - Nov 3, 2002
EAPoe Society of Baltimore transcript of Eureka
At Amazon Strange Matters: Undiscovered Ideas at the Frontiers of Space and Time by Tom Siegfried
At Amazon The Bit and the Pendulum: From Quantum Computing to M Theory-The New Physics of Informationn by Tom Siegfried


7:43:19 PM    comment []

© Copyright 2002 Jack Vaughan.
 
November 2002
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Oct   Dec


Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website.

Subscribe to "Jack Vaughan's Radio Weblog" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.