Jonathan Westhues is the author and engineer who wrote about cloning Pro-X RFID cards. He offers this reply:
"It seems I was unclear: the Motorola Flexpass card that I worked with does not use challenge/response. My device is more than a reader; it is also a simulator. If I power the coil then I can read a legitimate card, and store its ID in memory. At that point if I replay that ID to a legitimate reader then the door does open. In every sense, I can clone that card.
"I could have performed the first operation with a commercial reader, but not the second.
"I am not familiar with the "Pro-x" trademark, and I do not know whether those cards use challenge/response. However, my Motorola Flexpass card, and every other card that I've chanced to encounter, do not.
"As far as I can tell, there is no other information on that card. I have never tried to use it to do anything but open a door, and my device, having cloned my legitimate card, will do that." |