Kevin Schofield's Weblog
Musings on life, kids, work, the Internet, Microsoft, politics, orcas, etc.





Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.
 

 

Sunday, March 21, 2004
 

One more irrational, fact-twisting rant from Dan Gillmor.

Let's see if we can set the facts straight:

Settlement from 2001: Read the reports to the judge and the transcripts of the hearings. Microsoft has completely complied, and on more than one instance, the government praised Microsoft for being so cooperative. No one has any evidence as to whether the low number of licensses is because of the terms (which the government had a say in) or just plain lack of interest. Says it right there in the documents. But MS has been asked repeatedly to ease the terms just in case that's it. Microsoft's response: "ok". Hard to find a lot of fault with that. Once again, read the paper trail; it's all there.

SCO: Microsoft ships operating systems, including support for Unix compatibility both in Windows NT and in Services for Unix. It stands to reason that there is intellectual property in SCO's possession that might read on those products, and so Microsoft legally needs a license to that IP. Independent of whether SCO has any claim against Linux, that was a straightforward intellectual-property licensing deal from everything I can see (and all I know is what I read in the press and company's press releases). What SCO does with licensing fees is their damn business. Microsoft is following the intellectual property laws of this country and others; while there may not be a lot of case law about how they apply to open source and GPL, thee is a very large amount of case law interpreting them for proprietary products like Microsoft's, and the company is following those laws. On the BayStar thing, I have no information whatsoever on what Microsoft did or didn't do in this specific case. I can tell you, though, that people at Microsoft makes lots of introductions between VC's, investors, and tech companies all of the time. For years the VC community criticized the company for not being part of that ecosystem. So we've tried to step up that involvement and help people meet each other. So we're damned if we do, and damned if we don't... should Microsoft only make introductions between people and companies that everyone likes? In this business, that quickly brings the addressable market down to zero.

Lindows: Microsoft is suing Lindows under trademark law. The trademark laws, unlike patent laws, say that you must actively enforce your trademark, otherwise you lose it. Microsoft has no choice, it has to negotiate or litigate all of them. You can't do it selectively.  Same thing with mikerowesoft.com. Ask any trademark lawyer.

I understand that Dan is going to draw whatever conclusions he can from minimal evidence to reinforce his belief that Microsoft is evil. And that view certainly attracts an audience. But I hope that Gillmor isn't on the way to becoming the next Rush Limbaugh -- loudmouthed, headline-grabbing, and willing to selectively interpret the facts to support the view that will gain him the most blindly religious following. That would be a shame, because I do sometimes agree with him, and if he gets pulled into the abyss he would lose all credibility. And no one deserves that.


10:19:34 PM    ; comment []



Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website. © Copyright 2004 Kevin Schofield.
Last update: 8/23/2004; 10:09:12 PM.
This theme is based on the SoundWaves (blue) Manila theme.
March 2004
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      
Feb   Apr


Blogroll

Robert Scoble
Ross Mayfield
Dan Gillmor
Larry Lessig
Joi Ito
misbehaving.net
simplegeek
Ray Ozzie
Doc Searls
Boing Boing Blog
Paul Andrews
Chris Pirillo
Halley's Comment
Instapundit
Scripting News
Beyond the Beyond
Don Box
Mary Jo Foley
WebMink
Dean for America
kuro5hin
John Batelle
PDA and Tablet PC News
AlwaysOn Network
The Old New Thing
PR Opinions
Critical Section
Backup Brain
Seattle P-I Microsoft Blog

Books I Like

The Diamond Age
Cryptonomicon
The Tipping Point
The Art of Human-Computer Interface Design
The Design of Everyday Things
Contact
Earth
The Mythical Man-Month
Peopleware
Wicked French
Linked: The New Science of Networks
As the Future Catches You
Pattern Recognition
The Da Vinci Code
The Man who Stayed Behind
Angels and Demons
The Confusion
Quicksilver
Free Prize Inside


What I'm Reading Now

Bachelors Brothers Bed & Breakfast Pillow Book