vulgar morality : Blogging for the relationship between morality and freedom
Updated: 6/1/2005; 8:47:15 PM.

 

Subscribe to "vulgar morality" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.

Best Blogs Sophistpundit
Instapundit
Gateway Pundit
Publius Pundit
RealClearPolitics
Arts & Letters Daily
Becker-Posner Blog
Bjorn Staerk Blog
Iraq the Model
North Korea Zone
Amarji
Syria Exposed
Big Pharaoh
babalu blog

 
 

Sunday, May 15, 2005

NEVER SAY NEVER AGAIN:  A depressing observation made often in this blog concerns the tension between the moral imperative and the practical impossibility of preventing holocausts in places like Rwanda (or, for that matter, Nazi Germany).  Presently, horrors quite literally beyond the imagination of normal Americans take place every day in North Korea.  That has been the case for years:  in the mid-1990's for example, as many as 3 million North Koreans died of hunger.  The monstrosities perpetrated by the government against political prisoners are detailed here by Young Howard in the San Diego Union-Tribune.  They include arbitrary murder, forced abortion, and the extermination of the politically tainted unto the third generation.

 

The Union-Tribune should be applauded for bringing these facts to light.  Ritually, as always, the facts are followed by a recitation of previous holocausts and a call to action under the catchphrase "never again."

When Europe's Jews were being murdered by the millions during World War II, the world paid too little attention until it was too late. When 2 million Cambodians were dying in their country's auto-genocide in the mid to late 1970s, hardly anyone deigned to notice. When 800,000 ethnic Tutsis and Hutus were being slaughtered in Rwanda in 1994, the world knew but did nothing.

A repeat of this shameful neglect must not be permitted as North Korea's slave state brutally suppresses all dissenters, real and imagined, and millions remain at risk of starvation.

The Union-Trib editorial ends with the following plea:  "Above all, don't let it be said that the world knew of North Korea's horrors, and did nothing"  But isn't it already too late for that?  Hasn't the world known for years, and done nothing?  And what, beyond ensuring that the victims are remembered, can be done?  As I write, there are riots against the U.S. raging in Afghanistan and Pakistan; human rights groups are in a frenzy about the situation in Guantanamo and Iraq; the G-8 meeting in Britain will no doubt bring together huge crowds of anarchists and nihilists who deeply hate the free markets; but who in the world is angry enough to stir on behalf of the sorrow and the suffering and the deaths of North Koreans?

UPDATE:  I missed this piece in today's WaPo by one Paul Diehl ("Henning Larsen Professor of Political Science at the University of Illinois and director of the Correlates of War project, which collects data on international conflicts"), which explores possible international structures that can be tinkered with to prevent genocide.  Diehl's focus is Darfur.  No mention of North Korea.  His candidates for saving the world from mass murder are the UN, the EU, and the regional organizations such as the African Union; all are wisely dismissed.  The U.S. is never mentioned.  The question of a legitimizing authority remains unresolved.  Darfur is easy, yet all its people get is pious talk.  North Korea, being hard, is enveloped by a guilty silence.


9:24:16 PM    comment []

THE GREATEST AMERICANWhat would this country be like today, if George Washington hadn't been there at the start?  Anyone who has travelled a bit knows that, to some degree, a country gets the heroes it asks for.  From the Song of Roland to de Gaulle, the French have worshipped noble losers.  In honoring Juan and Evita Peron, the Argentines glorify the behaviors that destroyed their country.

George Washington, for his part, was all about self-command:  about character.  He towered above other Americans, then and now, and he made most of us walk a little taller than we would have without him.  He chose us, in some mysterious way available only to the very greatest.  This Newsweek essay by historian David McCullough, besides being a fun read, provides insight into how Washington managed to mold his character on our country - and, one hopes, on the rest of us.


3:00:13 PM    comment []

© Copyright 2005 Vulgar Morality.



Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website.
 


May 2005
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31        
Apr   Jun

Favorites

A million bloggers shouting


Art and morality


Women on the verge


Tradition and morality


Doh! Raising my kids on the Simpsons


John Paul II enters heaven


America and the Machiavellian moment


Freedom through the looking-glass


Moral monsters, viewed from afar


Freedom policy, command cultures


The liberals' freedom problem


Morality and the empty cradle


Terri Schiavo and human vanity


I,Robot vs Chinese room experiment


Thoughts on the tsunami


Jefferson and American virtue,1


Jefferson and American virtue,2


Jefferson and American virtue,3


Dictators: Moral universe of totalitarianism


Dictators: Guilt of the people