Dave's heart is in the right place. He does his best to make good, even significant, products at fair prices. And he truly cares about the wondrous potential, and need to maintain the integrity, of the Internet (I'm still giving him props for the fight against Microsoft's Smart Tags last year, even though he was mostly carrying Walter Mossberg's coattails on that one).
But the thing is, all you need to know about Dave boils down to two obsessions:
(1.) Outlining is God. An outliner is the ultimate application; you want and need one; it should be the hub and sum of all computing, creativity, and civilization.
(2.) So-called "journalists" are dinosaurs at best; most are contemptible hacks, and all are by definition merely paid shills of The Man and the BigCo conspiracy. Fiercely independent voices like Mossberg or Dan Gillmor, with their miles-long record of using their soapboxes to crusade against shoddy products, Microsoft's schemes, or dangers of corporate greed like the current digital copy-protection crisis, have done more for and better served the computing community than all Dave's work and wares. But because Gillmor merely notified his readers of a Knight-Ridder corporate site redesign that stupidly broke Web links, instead of shouting from rooftops, "The company I work for is evil and must be brought down," he is a whore, he is not a journalist.
(2a.) And in every line that Dave has ever written about journalism or tech reporting — often right on top, never more than an inch below the surface — a central, simmering outrage: How dare the media give more coverage to IBM, Sun, and Microsoft than to UserLand Software? It's just wrong! It proves they're incompetent, immoral sellouts!
9:11:21 AM
|
|