Dick Morley sent me his notes from our wide-ranging conversation with the folks at SoftSwitching Technology. One of the comments was that standards get in the way of innovation. This is a comment that makes sense--at least on the surface. Often, especially in technology, what emerges from the standards process is seldom the best possible technology.
However, consider these words from Dave Winer about inventing RSS:
In the world of standards the second-mover is the decision-maker, the first-mover is at the second guy's mercy. In the case of simple syndication formats, Netscape was the second mover, they blew off my earlier work. So I decided that I could either sulk about it, or do the powerful thing. Of course I did the powerful thing. I added all the features of their format to mine, which they responded to (as I thought they would) by adding all the features of my format to theirs. At that point, I had what I wanted, I put a bullet in the head of my format, and made RSS my cause.
Invention here is hardly the issue. What matters is adoption and forward motion.
Invention usually blows up standards and sets technology off in a different direction. However, standards enable widespread adoption. I think we need both.
1:39:20 PM
|
|