Data retention: Apropos of data retention issues noted below, this is from a Reuters article published in early October. The irony is that the "change in regime" we are now beginning to see across the EU, rather than strengthening protections, would instead loosen them insofar as how much information may be retained and for how long (the proposed Irish law would *increase* the typical time that data is kept under existing EU data protection directives by about 12 times):
BRUSSELS (Reuters) - The European Union is looking into possible amendments to its strict law for the protection of personal data after an online survey showed broad dissatisfaction with the current regime. A European Commission online survey involving over 10,000 respondents showed EU citizens felt their personal information was not sufficiently protected.
"The most striking result of the survey is that few citizens would define the level of data protection as high," Philippe Renaudiere, head of unit at the European Commission's Internal Market directorate general, told a conference...
Interested in sending a FAX or EMAIL to the Department of Justice on this issue? In my experience a fax or typed letter is more effective than an email.
DOJ fax number: +353 - 1 - 661-5461
Minister Michael McDowell: minister@justice.ie
5:59:32 PM # your two cents []
11:30:04 AM # your two cents []
11:29:06 AM # your two cents []
9:45:35 AM # your two cents []
9:44:46 AM # your two cents []
9:43:54 AM # your two cents []
9:43:23 AM # your two cents []
9:41:51 AM # your two cents []
Data retention: The Finnish branch of the Electronic Frontier Foundation has obtained and posted a leaked European Council of Ministers document on data retention plans of EU states. Ireland's answers are extremely interesting -- especially in the context of Justice Minister Michael McDowell's response on News At One yesterday to my story that his Department plans to introduce a data retention bill to require information about every Irish citizen's emails, faxes, web-surfing, mobile and landline calls to be retained for a minimum of three years. He claims his legislation is in extremely early draft form with no timeline or details decided and emphasised he has plans to consult widely with industry etc on the issue. As you can see from the document, for several months now Ireland has had plans to introduce the three+ year time period and notes that it has not consulted with industry and doesn;t seem to think it necessary as it doesn;t believe industry will "cause any problems". Amazing.
Here's the second, longer story on data retention that ran yesterday and here's one that is running today. The Minister is trying to play this down but it's a very serious civil rights and privacy issue.
Under the Department's proposals, Ireland would introduce one of the longest periods of data retention in the EU -- a total about-face to the pro-privacy stance taken in our 2000 E-Commerce Act, which is considered model legislation in this area. I urge anyone concerned to make an opinion known to the Department of Justice. For further information on the kinds of pan-European data retention moves afoot, see Statewatch.
9:14:17 AM # your two cents []
Copyright 2003 Karlin Lillington
Theme Design by Bryan Bell