Updated: 3/18/06; 6:46:33 AM.
Gary Mintchell's Feed Forward
Manufacturing and Leadership.
        

Sunday, December 18, 2005

A long and winding road. Here's a post from Steve Pazol on his M2M blog. He analyzes a cellular firm purchase by Sprint Nextel. It's a torturous discussion trying to figure out if this will be good for M2M as Steve knows it.

M2M can mean "machine-to-machine" communications. This is a type of SCADA system, but automated and more ubiquitous than that trationally know in process control or water/wastewater applications. The supposedly unique thing about what has been called M2M is that the communications is via cellular networks (rather than radio, wired line or Internet). Proponents quote the millions of devices that could be communicating as the potential market size.

My take on this has a couple of points. First, the cellular carriers seem to be increasingly discouraged about the huge incomes possible and seem to be bailing out. Couple with the second point--sure there are millions of devices, but where is the business model? It's still about the application. I don't think each of the millions of devices will need to dial up. Most likely the communications will go through aggregators and gateways. So the market size starts to shrink. Next companies will apply it only for applications that make sense. Only remote areas with cellular coverage (potentially an oxymoron) may be the economical locations. There are other wireless LANs under development that could be withering competition for cellular.

I asked Steve on his blog (but the M2M blog does not allow comments--a VERY un-bloglike policy) about the business model months ago. He's never responded. I think the business model lies with those companies who can leverage the entire suite of SCADA tools while proving the business value to their customers. In other words, let's expand the definition of M2M and its market potential.
6:12:09 PM    comment []


Whatever the merits of this article, it points to a challenge for capitalism. When the benefits stay with only the top 1% of the population, then capitalism will not gain acceptance by the people. When teamed with a stable, democratic political system, equal justice before the law and a thriving middle class, then we can prove capitalism's worth. Socialism is one of those theories that sounds great to people in need and idealists, but it breeds big government--something that doesn't work.

The World: Latin America Looks Leftward Again. The appeal of rural socialism is a powerful reminder that much of South America has become disenchanted with the promises of global capitalism. By JUAN FORERO. [NYT > Home Page]
5:42:03 PM    comment []


© Copyright 2006 Gary Mintchell.
 
December 2005
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Nov   Jan

Check out my magazine here:
Some favorite links:
Some automation company links:

Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website.

Subscribe to "Gary Mintchell's Feed Forward" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.