When the iPod first came out we got one at work to test for compatibility with Norton Utilities. I tried it out, but wasn't impressed--the sound quality was significantly worse than the same MP3s played on my Pismo. After that I forgot about the iPod, and didn't pay any attention when iPods and iTunes became compatible with Windows (I have a Windows system at home, but I don't like OS X).
Recently a friend wrote something on a web page which prompted me to take a look at the current generation of iPod. I then bought one of the 40GB models, and I've been pretty happy with it. The sound quality is much improved in the current generation, both in MP3 playback and by adding support for AAC.
There are still some lingering problems with playback of high notes at high volume in certain files, where a sort of staticy distortion occurs, but this seems to be pretty rare. I found that I could eliminate the problem by taking care to reencode an affected track using a higher bitrate with error correction turned on.
The user interface of the iPod works quite well. It does depend on the tags in the MP3 and AAC files, though, so it's important to make sure the tags are correct and complete. The CDDB (used to find information for CD tracks) and iTunes Music Store both are full of errors, so some effort by the user is required. For example, a recording of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony might list Wilhelm Furtwängler (the conducter) in the artist field, and leave the composer field empty. This would keep the recording from showing up on the iPod when browsing by composer.
Integration between the iPod and iTunes on my PC works very well. I don't have to do anything, just stick the iPod in its dock and syncing is automatic. Playlists can be created easily in iTunes by drag-and-drop, and dynamic searching makes it easy to find any track in a library that can easily have hundreds. The iTunes Music Store makes it easy to find and buy new music--it's even easier than Napster was.
The only flaw in the iPod hardware is the earbuds that come with it. They don't fit at all in my ears, and even if I hold them in place the sound quality is not too good. I purchased a pair of Etymotic ER-6 earphones to replace them, and am very satisfied. The ER-6 actually goes inside your ear, and blocks most outside sound--this makes them perfect for noisy bus rides. I think it would be a good idea for Apple's online store to offer better earphones with iPods as an option, similar to the "build to order" options for computers.
The battery life is about eight hours, which is enough for my commute to and from work, as well as listening more or less continuously in my cubicle. It takes about four hours to fully recharge the battery, and if using the dock the iPod will only recharge while the computer it's docked to is on (this might not be true of all computers).
Overall I'm quite satisfied with the 40GB iPod. It's definitely worth the money.
9:57:40 PM
|