My entries to wKen's wPhotoBlog are coming in dead-last.
Click these images to see the originals then be sure to leave a comment there!
Bang on Gong:
Max Jupiter published a condensed version of Gong BinXin's paper, that "proves" uncertainty to be wrong, in November, commenting only "What the hell is this". Easy reading if you're a math geek.
Then, last month, Joseph Anderson published it on about.com, and discussed the specific mistakes the author made. Not thinking of the microworld in classical terms is the biggest hurdle to understanding quantum theory. Illustrating how this leads to circular logic in this paper may be instructive indeed.
Dr. BingXin has achieved a goal of publishing his paper to a wide audience (it gets about a dozen hits here everyday) without going through a peer review process. If Gong is, as One Stone thought, a Chinese physics undergrad, he may encounter difficulties because of a wacko reputation. On the other-hand if he's an old fashioned science geek troll...
I feel so used.