Book Reviews


[Day Permalink] Wednesday, March 10, 2004

[Item Permalink]  -- Comment()
Sven-S. Porst described the experience of using EB 2003:
I've got 400MHz, so speed is an issue (2003 Britannica has this annoying 'slider' at the right which will slide in/out at a snail's pace if clicked accidentally). Search speed is also less than impressive.

Britannica has this 'root window' thing and lacks proper menus, respect for the Dock &c. That's well beyond acceptable. (It's like suggesting that, say, vi or KMail are Mac apps. They may run on a Mac, but they are not Mac applications.) It also spawns all those little sub windows with the widgets on the wrong side (which I find irritating every single times. Window close buttons have been at the top left since, forever, I guess.

Perhaps a few things have been improved since 2003, but your screenshot doesn't exactly look like that. So I am not inclined to upgrade. I find this trend particularly sad, as in the very early days of CD based encyclopaediae, Britannica had a really plain and simple multi-platform offering that made the full content available through a web browser. They didn't have 'multimedia' stuff, but even today Britannica doesn't seem to be en par with other offerings as far as non-text content is concerned. So it looks like a step backwards.


[Item Permalink]  -- Comment()
Jj commented on literary aspects of blogging: "If you are interested in the literary and scholarly aspects of blogging, check out the work of Jill Walker and Torill Mortensen. For example, they have written a paper titled "Blogging thoughts: personal publication as an online research tool". They also co-author Blogonblog, a blog about blogs which contains some interesting pointers." -- Thanks for these insights!


[Item Permalink]  -- Comment()
Schneier on Security As a Delusion: "Security always involves compromises. As a society we can have as much protection as we want, as long as we're willing to sacrifice the money, time, convenience, and liberties to get it. Unfortunately, most of the government's measures are bad trade-offs: They require significant sacrifices without providing much additional safety in return." [GrepLaw]


[Item Permalink] Blogging as literacy in Europe and Scandinavia -- Comment()
PT wrote asking about blogging as a pedagogical practice and literacy practice: "I am discovering that a lot of the ideas and writing on blogs is coming from Europe/Scandinavia. My question here is - can you point me in the direction of academic / reputable papers and info on blogging as a literacy practice ala, Gunter Kress, the logic of the page, and C. Lankshear, Rebecca Blood, etc? The info in the field is rather far flung!"

I have not thought much about blogging as literacy. For me blogging is a practical matter of finding new ideas, and processing my own ideas for publication elsewhere. Perhaps a reader (if I still have some) could comment on the literacy aspect?


[Item Permalink] EB 2004: I bought it for the articles, not for the pictures -- Comment()
Sven-S. Porst had a further question on Google vs. Britannica:
I seem to have Britannica 2003. How much is the speed increase? What about the content, by the way? The last time I used Britannica was when on the train with my South African friend around the new year. There is no Google on trains and I wanted to show him where we are going on a map. I found the quality and usability of maps on the computerised Britannica rather disappointing, though. Having used the proper Britannica atlas, I know that they have much better material than what is offered in the electronic version. Simply not quitting Britannica may be an option if you use it regularly. But as it seems to be a Java rather than a proper Mac application it seems to be quite a memory hog as well. (This also accounts for its ugliness and ignorance of HIG, I suppose.)
I wrote here earlier: "I bought it for the articles, not for the pictures." So, the maps are not very useful. But the speed is about acceptable on my 1 GHz PowerBook G4. I have 1 GB of memory, so I have never had any trouble with too much memory in use on the PowerBook. The Java-based interface is ugly, but it is no worse than using Windows, which I also have to do every so often.


[Item Permalink] More about the ignorance society -- Comment()
Jason commented my entry on a new column: "Where can I read this article?"

The column is written in Finnish. It will appear in the next print issue of the MikroPC Magazine. Here is a short summary of the column:

Finland is in a hurry to move from an information society towards a knowledge society. However, in reality it seems that we are slipping from a data society towards an ingnorance society. All kinds of pseudoscience rules, and it matters not _what_ you know. Instead, _who_ you know is important. The decision-making inner circle is more interested in euros and gigahertz' than in watts and becquerels.
So, in the column I look at Finland in 2010, to see what kind of society we'll build on this foundation. This part of the column is written as a story which tells of a society based on advanced IT infrastructure with strict security control and pseudoscientific decision-making. Sounds like fun? It is.