Opinion: Smart growth's misunderstood message. Published Saturday, October 16, 2004, in the Washington Post Smart Growth's Misunderstood Message [BATN at Yahoo! Groups]
While I understand and appreciate the goals of smart growth policies, I think that there are times and places where have to realize that any growth is dumb. Another way to put this is that sometimes the only smart growth is no growth.
The San Francisco Bay Area is rapidly approaching that point, if it isn't already there. There is no room for further road expansion. The costs for new or expanded transit systems (ie BART) are so high, they essentially kill off all other transit improvements. And finally, topography and geology limit further outward growth. Further growth degrades the quality of life for everyone.
Further growth in the Bay Area, dictates sprawl in outlying areas of Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, Monterey, Stanislaus, Merced, and other counties. And while we may envision a "smart growth" community in the Coyote Valley, the reality in the outlying counties is suburban sprawl, plain and simple.
If you want see it in action, go to Patterson, or Newman, or Los Banos. These towns are following the classic sprawl concepts of turning farmlands in to suburbs. Unfortunately, the nearest urban areas are 20 miles away, while jobs in the Bay Area are at least 60 to 90 miles away. How is this smart?
And how smart is the "community" in Coyote Valley when there are only two transit options (Caltrain and VTA busses), two roads, and one freeway connecting a projected 50,000 residents with jobs in San Jose and the Peninsula. While developers and planners see opportunities, I see see gridlock.
The growth projections for California and the Bay Area are absurd. To sustain the growth, we need to convert farmland to housing. With the loss of farmland, we become more reliant on food imports. What happens if the import supply chain is disrupted?
Also, I have yet to see a plan to supply water to the population that doesn't further degrade the environment by flooding rivers (new dams) or creating local hypersaline environments (desalinification of ocean water).
Growth beyond a region's ability to support it is dumb. Pushing growth beyond that is even dumber.
5:30:03 AM
|