Common Sense on Cloning
I've never really understood the hysteria around the issue of human cloning.
Wait. Let me restate. I think it's perfectly reasonable to vehemently oppose human cloning for the purpose of harvesting organs, creating slaves-soldiers-workers, or in general turning a human being into a means for someone else's ends. Human beings must always be treated as ends in themselves.
But aside from exploitation (and let's face it, people have been reproducing to create little slaves for their own purposes from time immemorial), I can't subscribe to any of the objections.
1. "It's not natural." Neither is 99% of our culture. The same objection was raised to every advance in science and medicine. Hey, lots of the biomass on the planet reproduces asexually, essentially cloning itself itself. Feh on this argument from nature.
2. "The clone will never be able to have his or her own identity." Unlike all those "natural" children raised in dysfunctional families who had to live out the lives, fantasies, or phobias of their parents? If identical twins can manage to have a sense of self, so can a clone. At the very least, they'll know they were really wanted.
3. "Anyone who wants to be cloned is a horrible egotist and would make a lousy parent." As opposed to all those perfect parents out there who procreate for only the most pure and righteous of reasons? Helloooooo? What world do YOU live in? Any pair of fools with functional gonads can create a child, and they do. We don't require a license for them. We don't require them to study good parenting. We don't watch them like hawks to be sure they are raising their children in a sane and healthy manner. (We could have another discussion about whether we should.) I think it's quite likely that the parent of a clone will treat that child pretty well ~ after all, it should be even easier to be empathetic.
4. "It will cheapen the miracle of human life by making it more of a market commodity." Gene tailoring is coming. Like it or not (and I'm inclined to NOT like it, except for eliminating identifiable diseases). The biggest surprise awaiting the first person to be successfully cloned will be how very different the new child is. Individuality does not reside in DNA alone, but in a complex interaction that commences at conception and may or may not end in the grave.
Wired News has an article about Randolfe Wicker, a man who speaks sense about cloning.
3:03:25 PM |