The Process at Work
I spoke today with Ed McDonald, chief of staff for Howard Coble. He says that Coble got a lot of questions about the corporate hacking bill (as described in my column) while making the rounds of civic clubs and such here in his district last week. McDonald also called News & Record editorial-page editor Allen Johnson this morning to discuss Saturday's editorial on the subject. Coble's office has gotten about 50 emails about the bill so far--anything over a dozen makes them really sit up and pay attention.
Coble will probably publish a response soon in the N&R--judging from what I heard from him and from Ed McDonald, the argument will be that the bill is written tightly enough so that private files on your desktop won't be open to attack. I don't think that addresses the technical issues at hand, or the privacy and property issues either. But it is the next step in the conversation.
McDonald says Coble would like to hold hearings on this bill in September, and that both sides may be able to participate. It is important that the public response continues (howard.coble@mail.house.gov).
Some people are pushing back via email that I'm playing too nice here, that I should be blasting Coble as an ignoramus or a sell-out. There are a couple of reasons that I'm not doing that: it isn't what I think, and it wouldn't be effective.
I think Howard Coble respects privacy and property rights, and that he is willing to listen and learn, and that making laws is often a long process. But even if I thought his stances were cynical, I would exploit his public image as a champion of the regular guy to make him live up to it. Dave Winer quotes Tip O'Neill that all politics are local, and the local truth is that polite conversation can be very effective in this district and with this congressman.
I think the bill will be altered and that the public will come out of this better informed and better connected. That's critical: regardless of what happens in the November elections, Coble will rotate out of his chairmanship next year, and the battle will shift to someone else's district. The biggest story to come out of this won't be the specifics of the legislation, but an important evolutionary step in the interplay of Weblogs, print journalism, and old-fashioned constituent-level politics.
12:57:17 PM
|